Carrie: (340) 643-1400
Meghan: (340) 998-5272

See ALL St. John Dining Recommendations

Extra Virgin Bistro
St. John
(340) 715-7864
Cruz Bay
Reservations Recommended

Visit their website for more information
Follow on Facebook and Instagram


My FAVORITE place to go for a nice dinner on STJ. Reservations are strongly recommended here as the place is usually packed with locals and tourists. It stays packed for good reason. Their gnocchi appetizer is worth the trip alone. They make all of their pasta in-house and always have mouth-watering specials.

Make sure to ask the server or bartender what the specials are that night. They sell out quickly. Oh, that’s another thing, they take reservations for the bar, which is where my husband and prefer to sit.  

Hours are subject to change, visit their website for more information.
Tuesday through Sunday 5:30 pm – 9 pm

Check out these other recommendations…

Morgan’s Mango

Morgan’s Mango

Around since 1992 and recently renovated, thanks to financial help from Kenny Chesney after hurricanes Irma and Maria ripped it apart, this restaurant delivers delicious food, consistently.

read more
The Terrace

The Terrace

A French-inspired restaurant, with a great view of the sunset. I love their Foie Gras and pork belly appetizers. For dinner, you can go wrong with their Wahoo, filet or crab stuffed prawns.

read more